Defending Cato from the Predictably Inaccurate Ramblings of Paul Krugman

 

Writing for the New York Times, Paul Krugman has a new column promoting more government spending and additional government regulation. That’s a dog-bites-man revelation and hardly noteworthy, of course, but in this case he takes a swipe at the Cato Institute.

The financial crisis of 2008 and its painful aftermath…were a huge slap in the face for free-market fundamentalists. …analysts at right-wing think tanks like…the Cato Institute…insisted that deregulated financial markets were doing just fine, and dismissed warnings about a housing bubble as liberal whining. Then the nonexistent bubble burst, and the financial system proved dangerously fragile; only huge government bailouts prevented a total collapse.

Upon reading this, my first reaction was a perverse form of admiration. After all, Krugman explicitly advocated for a housing bubble back in 2002, so it takes a lot of chutzpah to attack other people for the consequences of that bubble.

 

He likes cats, so he’s not all bad

 

But let’s set that aside and examine the accusation that folks at Cato had a Pollyanna view of monetary and regulatory policy. In other words, did Cato think that “deregulated markets were doing just fine”?

Hardly. If Krugman had bothered to spend even five minutes perusing the Cato website, he would have found hundreds of items by scholars such as Steve Hanke, Gerald O’Driscoll, Bert Ely, and others about misguided government regulatory and monetary policy. He could have perused the remarks of speakers at Cato’s annual monetary conferences. He could have looked at issues of the Cato Journal. Or ourbiennial Handbooks on Policy.

The tiniest bit of due diligence would have revealed that Cato was not a fan of Federal Reserve policy and we did not think that financial markets were deregulated. Indeed, Cato scholars last decade were relentlessly critical of monetary policy, Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, Community Reinvestment Act, and other forms of government intervention.

Heck, I imagine that Krugman would have accused Cato of relentless and foolish pessimism had he reviewed our work  in 2006 or 2007.

I will confess that Cato people didn’t predict when the bubble would peak and when it would burst. If we had that type of knowledge, we’d all be billionaires. But since Krugman is still generating income by writing columns and doing appearances, I think it’s safe to assume that he didn’t have any special ability to time the market either.

Krugman also implies that Cato is guilty of historical revisionism.

…many on the right have chosen to rewrite history. Back then, they thought things were great, and their only complaint was that the government was getting in the way of even more mortgage lending; now they claim that government policies, somehow dictated by liberals even though the G.O.P. controlled both Congress and the White House, were promoting excessive borrowing and causing all the problems.

I’ve already pointed out that Cato was critical of government intervention before and during the bubble, so we obviously did not want government tilting the playing field in favor of home mortgages.

It’s also worth nothing that Cato has been dogmatically in favor of tax reform that would eliminate preferences for owner-occupied housing. That was our position 20 years ago. That was our position 10 years ago. And it’s our position today.

I also can’t help but comment on Krugman’s assertion that GOP control of government last decade somehow was inconsistent with statist government policy. One obvious example would be the 2004 Bush Administration regulations that dramatically boosted the affordable lending requirements for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, which surely played a role in driving the orgy of subprime lending.

And that’s just the tip of the iceberg. The burden of government spending almost doubled during the Bush years, the federal government accumulated more power, and the regulatory state expanded. No wonder economic freedom contracted under Bush after expanding under Clinton.

But I’m digressing. Let’s return to Krugman’s screed. He doesn’t single out Cato, but presumably he has us in mind when he criticizes those who reject Keynesian stimulus theory.

…right-wing economic analysts insisted that deficit spending would destroy jobs, because government borrowing would divert funds that would otherwise have gone into business investment, and also insisted that this borrowing would send interest rates soaring. The right thing, they claimed, was to balance the budget, even in a depressed economy.

Actually, I hope he’s not thinking about us. We argue for a smaller burden of government spending, not a balanced budget. And we haven’t made any assertions about higher interest rates. We instead point out that excessive government spending undermines growth by undermining incentives for productive behavior and misallocating labor and capital.

But we are critics of Keynesianism for reasons I explain in this video. And if you look at current economic performance, it’s certainly difficult to make the argument that Obama’s so-called stimulus was a success

 

Zombie

 

But Krugman will argue that the government should have squandered even more money. Heck, he even asserted that the 9-11 attacks were a form of stimulus and has argued that it would be pro-growth if we faced the threat of an alien invasion.

In closing, I will agree with Krugman that there’s too much “zombie” economics in Washington. But I’ll let readers decide who’s guilty of mindlessly staggering in the wrong direction.

 

Read Original Article @TownHall

241 comments

  1. jessie says:

    .

    áëàãîäàðþ….

  2. Angel says:

    .

    áëàãîäàðþ….

  3. ferragamo shoes…

    north face coats outlet,north face coats clearancenorth face jackets on saleprada shoes outlet,prada handbags outlet…

  4. nfl 17 jerseys cheap…

    nfl 17 jerseys cheap; nfl 17 jerseys cheap; nfl 17 jerseys cheap; nfl 17 jerseys cheap; nfl 17 jerseys cheap; nfl 17 jerseys cheap; nfl 17 jerseys cheap; nfl 17 jerseys cheap;…

  5. coach outlet says:

    coach outlet…

    burberry outlet coach factory outlet burberry outlet online burberry sale burberry sale burberry outlet coach outlet north face outlet north face jackets on sale north face store north face jackets clearance michael kors factory outlet michael kors pur…

  6. factory outlet michael kors handbags…

    burberry聽outlet coach factory outlet burberry outlet online burberry sale burberry sale burberry outlet coach outlet north face outlet north face jackets on sale north face store north face jackets clearance michael kors factory outlet michael kors pur…

  7. jordan 11 says:

    jordan 11…

    burberry聽outlet coach factory outlet burberry outlet online burberry sale burberry sale burberry outlet coach outlet north face outlet north face jackets on sale north face store north face jackets clearance michael kors factory outlet michael kors pur…

  8. hermes belt says:

    hermes belt…

    burberry outlet coach factory outlet 70% off burberry outlet burberry outlet burberry sale burberry handbags coach wallets coach store coach outlet online coach handbags north face outlet north face jackets on sale north face factory outlet the north f…

  9. louboutin outlet…

    burberry outlet coach factory outlet burberry outlet online burberry sale burberry sale burberry outlet coach outlet north face outlet north face jackets on sale north face store north face jackets clearance michael kors factory outlet michael kors pur…

  10. burberry outlet online…

    burberry scarf coach factory outlet 70% off burberry outlet burberry outlet burberry scarf burberry handbags coach wallets coach store coach outlet online coach handbags north face outlet 70% off north face sale north face factory outlet the north face…

  11. coach shoes for women…

    burberry scarf coach factory outlet 70% off burberry outlet burberry outlet burberry scarf burberry handbags coach wallets coach store coach outlet online coach handbags north face outlet 70% off north face sale north face factory outlet the north face…

  12. coach outlet online…

    [url=http://www.burberryscarfoutlet.net]burberry outlet[/url] [url=http://www.coachfactoryoutlet70off.com]coach factory outlet 70% off[/url] [url=http://www.burberryoutlet-online.net]burberry outlet[/url] [url=http://www.burberryoutlet-sale.com]burberr…

  13. coach outlet says:

    coach outlet…

    burberry聽scarf coach factory outlet 70% off burberry outlet burberry outlet burberry scarf burberry handbags coach wallets coach store coach outlet online coach handbags north face outlet 70% off north face sale north face factory outlet the north face…

  14. louis vuitton outlet…

    north face jackets north face sale,north face coats salenorth face denali north face outletburberry聽outlet coach factory outlet burberry outlet online burberry sale burberry sale burberry outlet coach outlet north face outlet north face jackets on sale…

  15. louis vuitton outlet…

    burberry outlet coach factory outlet burberry outlet online burberry sale burberry sale burberry outlet coach outlet north face outlet north face jackets on sale north face store north face jackets clearance michael kors factory outlet michael kors pur…

  16. gucci outlet says:

    gucci outlet…

    north face clearance north face sale north face denali jacket north face outlet burberry聽scarf coach factory outlet 70% off burberry outlet burberry outlet burberry scarf burberry handbags coach wallets coach store coach outlet online coach handbags no…

  17. nike free says:

    nike free…

    [url=http://www.burberryscarfoutlet.net]burberry scarf[/url] [url=http://www.coachfactoryoutlet70off.com]coach factory outlet 70% off[/url] [url=http://www.burberryoutlet-online.net]burberry outlet online[/url] [url=http://www.burberryoutlet-sale.com]b…

  18. north face jackets…

    coach factory outlet 80% offcoach outlet online 70% offcoach clearancecoach sunglasses coach shoes for women coach sale coach factory outletferragamo shoessalvatore ferragamo salesalvatore ferragamo belt nike shoes online north face outlet store north …

  19. marc jacobs bags…

    burberry聽scarf coach factory outlet 70% off burberry outlet burberry outlet burberry scarf burberry handbags coach wallets coach store coach outlet online coach handbags north face outlet 70% off north face sale north face factory outlet the north face…

  20. coach factory…

    the north face backpacks air max 2015 ugg boots on sale michael kors factory outlet online official ugg shoes louis vuitton belts hermes outlet coach outlet michael kors handbags hermes bags coach factory outlet 70% off louis vuitton outlet online coac…

  21. red sole shoes christian louboutin…

    louis vuitton ferragamo outlet coach outlet online 70% off burberry scarf north face jackets coach factory online north face outlet coach outlet stores online shopping chanel sunglasses louboutin outlet north face outlet 70% off http://www.coachfactory.com ch…

  22. canada goose outlet…

    coach purses nike factory outlet ugg boots louis vuitton outlet coach sunglasses canada goose jackets coach outlet marc jacobs handbags coach store michael kors handbags coach factory north face outlet 70% off outlet michael kors online coach factory o…

  23. burberry sale…

    ugg boots sale ugg boots gucci bags ugg factory outlet online chanel bags louis vuitton outlet the north face outlet burberry聽scarf christian louboutin jordan 12 chanel purses burberry outlet coach outlet michael kors factory outlet coach purses air ma…

  24. ugg outlet online…

    ugg boots for women north face outlet michael kors outlet christian louboutin coach handbags louis vuitton outlet online nike shoes louboutin shoes canada goose jackets louis vuitton handbags north face ferragamo belts timberland boots north face sale …

  25. hermes outlet…

    louis vuitton handbags burberry聽outlet gucci outlet online coach factory outlet 80% off canada goose outlet chanel sunglasses hermes outlet coach factory outlet timberland outlet louis vuitton outlet coach factory outlet timberland outlet chaussure lou…

  26. coach diaper bag…

    burberry sale gucci handbags ugg boots on sale 70% off louis vuitton outlet online coach handbags coach outlet store online north face outlet coach outlet air jordan 14 north face store chanel handbags coach handbags christian louboutin outlet louis vu…

  27. cheap ugg boots for sale…

    [URL=http://www.canadagoose-jackets-outlet.com]canada goose outlet[/URL] [URL=http://www.timberland-boots-outlet.com]timberland femme[/URL] [URL=http://www.northfacejackets-clearance.in.net]north face jackets clearance[/URL] [URL=http://www.uggboots-on…

  28. michael kors purses on sale…

    ugg boots michael kors handbags {louboutin outlet north face coats for women jordan 14 ugg store ugg boots michael kors purses red bottom {north face sale {coach sunglasses ferragamo belt christian louboutin outlet ugg boots on sale 70% off authentic l…

  29. the north face outlet…

    coach outlet store online north face outlet gucci outlet online gucci shoes for men coach handbags ugg boots on sale louis vuitton outlet ugg boots outlet ugg boots louis vuitton outlet coach factory outlet louis vuitton purses jordan 11 michael kors p…

  30. nike outlet says:

    nike outlet…

    coach sunglasses ugg boots on sale nike factory storenike factory ugg boots outletugg outlet coach factory outlet 80% off prada outlet ferragamo outlet coach factory outlet online store north face outlet hermes belt coach outlet north face factory outl…

  31. coach bags says:

    coach bags…

    factory outlet michael kors handbags coach outlet stores nike store outlet michael kors online nike outlet michael kors coach shoes hermes bags louis vuitton wallets chanel purses ferragamo outlet michael kors factory outlet online official north face …

  32. north face coats for women…

    ferragamo belts louis vuitton outlet stores ferragamo sale north face outlet north face outlet gucci belts michael kors outlet online sale louis vuitton handbags ugg boots sale louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton purses jordan 14 jordan 12 louis vuitton…

  33. George says:

    .

    thanks for information!!…

  34. coach factory outlet…

    [URL=http://www.michaelkorsoutlethandbags-inc.com]michael kors handbags[/URL] [URL=http://www.michael--kors-outlet.com]michael kors outlet[/URL] [URL=http://www.burberryoutlet-online.net]burberry outlet online[/URL] [URL=http://www.louisvuittonoutlet-s…

  35. chanel sunglasses…

    michael kors outlet north face outlet store coach purses cheap louis vuitton bags coach factory online ugg boots clearance factory outlet michael kors handbags prada shoes coach bags hermes outlet ugg outlet store nike outlet burberry handbags louis vu…

  36. ugg sale says:

    ugg sale…

    nike outlet store louboutin shoes louis vuitton wallets the north face ugg outlet store jordan retro 11 ferragamo belt chanel bags gucci bags ugg boots louis vuitton wallet north face outlet 70% off cheap louis vuitton bags chanel bags gucci belt disco…

  37. chanel sunglasses…

    chanel handbags jordan 3 louis vuitton outlet stores north face outlet 70% off cheap jordan shoes louis vuitton handbags outlet factory outlet michael kors handbags ugg boots on sale 70% off ugg boots north face denali michael kors handbags clearance n…